Parenting in Hokkien
Nurturing the Future: An In-Depth Report on Hokkien Infant Rearing Practices, from Ancient Rituals to Modern Science

Thuy Bui
Introduction: The World of the Hokkien Child
Defining the Hokkien People and Minnan Culture
The Hokkien, or Hoklo, people represent a significant Han Chinese subgroup whose cultural origins are deeply rooted in the southern coastal province of Fujian in southeastern China.1 Their name is a direct linguistic link to their homeland, as "Hokkien" is the Minnan pronunciation of "Fujian".1 This region, historically known as Min, has cultivated a distinct cultural identity known as Minnan culture, which is characterized by its unique linguistic features—the Minnan dialect—and a strong maritime orientation.4 For centuries, Fujian's strategic position on the coast made it a vital hub for maritime trade, serving as a starting point for the ancient Maritime Silk Road and fostering extensive contact with Southeast Asia and the wider world.4
This history of seafaring and commerce has been a primary driver of Hokkien migration. Beginning in the 17th century, large numbers of Hokkien people, primarily from the prefectures of Quanzhou and Zhangzhou, began emigrating from Fujian, establishing significant communities in Taiwan, which is now a major center of Hokkien culture, as well as in Singapore, Malaysia, the Philippines, Indonesia, and other parts of Southeast Asia.7 This diaspora has made Hokkien one of the most widely spoken Chinese dialects outside of mainland China.10 The culture they carried with them was not a static monolith but a dynamic system that had already absorbed diverse influences over centuries. Minnan culture itself is a rich tapestry woven from the threads of the indigenous Minyue peoples who inhabited the region before Sinicization, successive waves of Han Chinese migrants from the Central Plains, and the cultural exchanges brought by Arab, Persian, and European traders who frequented its bustling ports.1 This historical reality has endowed Hokkien culture with a remarkable dual character: a deep-seated commitment to traditional Chinese values and an inherent adaptability to new environments and ideas.
Central Thesis Statement
This report posits that Hokkien child-rearing is a dynamic and resilient system of cultural transmission, shaped by this unique historical and cultural context. It is not a static collection of ancient customs but a living tradition where deeply rooted philosophies of familial obligation, spiritual protection, and collective well-being are continuously negotiated with the pressures and insights of globalization, modern science, and evolving social structures. Through an exhaustive examination of practices ranging from prenatal rituals and postpartum confinement to naming ceremonies and disciplinary philosophies, this analysis will demonstrate that the Hokkien approach to raising an infant is a complex synthesis of the old and the new. It is a system that reveals how a culture with a profound reverence for its past adapts to the demands of the present to secure the future for its youngest members.
Part I: The Cultural Bedrock: Foundations of the Hokkien Family
The practices and rituals surrounding the birth and care of a Hokkien infant do not occur in a vacuum. They are the tangible expressions of a profound and deeply ingrained cultural philosophy that defines the family's structure, its purpose, and the individual's role within it. To understand how a Hokkien baby is raised is to first understand the cultural and ethical environment into which it is born—an environment built upon the foundational principles of the family as a societal cornerstone and filial piety as the ultimate virtue.
The Family as the Nation's Cell: The Primacy of the Jiā (家)
In traditional Chinese thought, which forms the bedrock of Hokkien values, the family, or jiā (家), is conceptualized as the most essential unit of society. An ancient saying holds that "The family is essential under Heaven," reflecting the belief that the well-being of the nation is inextricably linked to the health of its families.12 This perspective elevates the family from a private, domestic sphere to a public institution with immense social and political significance. Family harmony is seen as a direct contributor to social stability, family happiness is a prerequisite for social peace, and the civility practiced within the family is the model for civility in society at large.12
This belief instills the act of child-rearing with a profound sense of social duty. Parents are not merely raising an individual child for that child's own sake; they are cultivating a future member of society whose character, conduct, and accomplishments will reflect upon the entire lineage, the community, and ultimately, the nation.12 The family is considered the "first school," and parents are the child's "first teachers".12 The education provided within the home, particularly in the realm of character-building, is believed to determine a person's future conduct and their capacity to be a useful and contributing member of society.12 This imbues parenting with a weight of responsibility that extends far beyond the individual, framing it as a critical act of cultural and civic continuity.
The Root of All Virtue: Filial Piety (Xiào 孝) and Its Implications for Child-Rearing
At the heart of the Chinese family structure, and therefore at the core of Hokkien parenting philosophy, is the paramount virtue of filial piety, or xiào (孝). Described in the Confucian Classic of Filial Piety as the "root of virtue and the basis of philosophy," xiào is the principle of exhibiting profound love, respect, support, and obedience towards one's parents, elders, and ancestors.14 It is considered the most fundamental of the five cardinal relationships (wǔlún) described by Confucius and serves as the ideological basis for traditional Chinese society.14
This principle establishes a clear and enduring family hierarchy and dictates a set of lifelong, reciprocal obligations that define the parent-child relationship. This relationship is not conceived as one of equals but as one of mutual duty and interdependence.14 The parents' duty is to provide for the child physically, to educate them in moral conduct and cultural traditions, to find them a spouse, and to leave them a good heritage.14 The father is traditionally expected to be "stern and dignified," while the mother is to be "gentle and compassionate".14
In return, the child's obligations are comprehensive and unconditional. Filial piety requires a child to not only provide physical care and material support for parents in their old age but also to engage in good conduct throughout their life so as to bring a good name to their parents and ancestors.14 It involves displaying courtesy, ensuring the continuation of the family line (traditionally through male heirs), wisely advising one's parents, and showing proper reverence for them in sickness and in death.14 Crucially, this includes a high degree of obedience. While a child is permitted to dissuade a parent from moral unrighteousness, Confucian ethics dictate that if the parent does not listen, the child must ultimately still obey; outright rebellion is never approved.14 This framework creates a psychological and social environment where respect for authority, deference to elders, and the sublimation of individual desires for the good of the family collective are primary values taught from the earliest age.
The traditional ideal of filial piety is one of harmonious reciprocity, a system of mutual care and obligation that ensures the well-being of all family members and, by extension, the stability of society.12 However, the practical application of this deeply held cultural value reveals a significant tension. While it is lauded as the cornerstone of morality, modern psychological research has increasingly highlighted the potential for negative mental health outcomes when filial piety is interpreted and enforced in a rigid, authoritarian manner. Studies have linked such applications to increased anxiety, depression, lower self-esteem, the suppression of personal autonomy, and even a higher risk of suicidal ideation in children who feel trapped by the immense pressure to meet parental expectations.16
This apparent contradiction does not necessarily invalidate the cultural principle itself but rather points to its complex nature. Filial piety is not a monolithic concept. It can be understood as existing on a spectrum. At one end lies "reciprocal filial piety," which is based on genuine affection, gratitude, and a spontaneous desire to care for one's parents, born from a lifetime of positive interaction.17 At the other end is "authoritarian filial piety," which demands unquestioning submission to hierarchical authority and the oppression of self-will.17 The psychological impact on a child, therefore, is not determined by the existence of the value of xiào but by how that value is enacted within the family. Discussions within contemporary Asian communities acknowledge that this cultural ideal can be, and sometimes is, used as a tool for emotional blackmail, where parents direct their children's lives for the primary purpose of securing their own future comfort.18 This inherent tension between the ideal of loving reciprocity and the potential reality of hierarchical control is a central and defining dynamic in the landscape of Hokkien parenting.
Part II: The Sacred Transition: Birth and the Postpartum Period
The period immediately surrounding childbirth is considered a time of profound transition and vulnerability for both mother and infant in Hokkien culture. It is a liminal state, where the boundaries between the physical and spiritual worlds are porous and the new family is susceptible to both physical illness and malevolent influences. In response, a comprehensive system of rituals, taboos, and specialized care has evolved over centuries. This system is designed to protect the unborn, heal the mother, and secure the infant's safe passage into the world.
Protecting the Unborn: Prenatal Rituals and Taboos
The protective measures begin long before the child is born. Hokkien culture, in line with broader Chinese tradition, observes a host of prenatal practices that function as a form of spiritual and physical prophylaxis for the expectant mother and her fetus.19 These practices are a mixture of avoidance behaviors and proactive rituals.
The taboos are largely centered on the belief that the fetus is in a delicate state and should not be disturbed by sudden changes in its environment. Consequently, expectant mothers are strongly discouraged from moving furniture, engaging in home renovations, or even using scissors near the bed, as these actions are thought to risk causing a miscarriage or physical defects in the child.19 Dietary restrictions are also common; for instance, some believe that eating pineapple can induce a miscarriage or that consuming lamb could cause the baby to develop epilepsy, a belief rooted in the similar pronunciation of the words for "lamb" and "epilepsy" in some Chinese dialects.20 A significant social taboo involves pregnant women avoiding funerals, as it is believed that the exposure to the energies of death could bring misfortune or spiritual harm to the unborn infant.21
Alongside these prohibitions are active rituals aimed at securing fertility and ensuring a healthy pregnancy. A notable Hokkien tradition, with roots in the ancestral homelands of Quanzhou and Zhangzhou, is the Xun Hua Cong (巡花丛), or "Flower Picking" ritual.21 This practice is based on the belief that every woman possesses a spiritual counterpart in the form of a flower shrub in the celestial realm. The health and vitality of this shrub are directly linked to her fertility and the well-being of her children. The flowers on the shrub are thought to represent her future offspring, with white flowers signifying boys and red flowers signifying girls. If a woman experiences difficulty conceiving, it is attributed to a problem with her flower shrub—perhaps it is withered or infested with pests. Rituals are then performed, often involving prayers and offerings to specific deities, to tend to this spiritual plant and thereby ensure a successful pregnancy and a healthy child.21
Healing the Mother, Securing the Child: The Art and Science of Ge Lai (坐月子)
The culmination of this protective system is the postpartum confinement period, known in Hokkien as ge lai and in Mandarin as zuo yuezi (坐月子), which literally translates to "sitting the month".22 This traditional 30-day period of intensive care is arguably the most critical and elaborate ritual in Hokkien child-rearing. It is founded on principles of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), which posits that the act of childbirth is a profoundly depleting event. The mother loses a significant amount of blood and qi (life force), leaving her body in a state of "cold" (yin) and weakness.24 This imbalance makes both her and her highly vulnerable newborn susceptible to illness, chronic future ailments, and negative spiritual influences.20 The entire regimen of ge lai is designed to restore her body's "heat" (yang), replenish her vital energy, and shield the infant during its fragile first month of life.
The core practices of ge lai are comprehensive and highly structured:
Dietary Regimen: The diet is the primary tool for restoring the mother's internal balance. It is strictly limited to foods classified in TCM as "warm" or "heating" (yang-promoting). Key ingredients include ginger, which is believed to expel "wind" and warm the body; sesame oil; and rice wine.24 Meals are typically rich in protein and iron to replenish blood and energy, with a heavy emphasis on soups and broths made from black chicken, fish, or pork trotters simmered with herbs.26 Conversely, "cold" (yin) foods are strictly forbidden. This category includes not only iced drinks and raw foods like salads and most fruits but also other foods believed to have a "cooling" effect on the body, such as crab, cucumber, and seaweed.22
Physical Restrictions: To conserve energy and prevent the intrusion of "wind" (feng) into her weakened body, the mother's physical activity is severely restricted. She is expected to remain indoors for the entire month, avoid all strenuous chores, and spend most of her time resting in bed.22 One of the most well-known and stringent prohibitions is against bathing or washing her hair, as it is believed that contact with water will allow "cold" and "wind" to penetrate her joints and pores, leading to future health problems like arthritis, rheumatism, and chronic headaches.22 In modern times, many families adapt this rule. Instead of complete avoidance, they may permit sponge baths with water that has been boiled with herbs like guava leaves, which are thought to have healing properties, or they may rely on modern conveniences like dry shampoo and no-rinse body wipes.24
Social Seclusion: The confinement period is also a time of social isolation. The mother and baby are kept away from crowds and visitors to protect them from infectious diseases at a time when their immune systems are compromised.20 This seclusion also has a spiritual dimension, shielding them from negative energies. In some communities, there is a belief that praising a newborn can attract the attention of jealous spirits who might cause the child to fall ill or be taken away, leading to a custom of avoiding compliments during this early period.20
The traditional practice of ge lai is fundamentally a system of protection, meticulously designed within a pre-scientific framework to address the very real dangers of the postpartum period, such as infection, hemorrhage, and malnutrition. However, when viewed through the lens of modern medical science and psychology, a complex picture emerges, revealing both convergences and significant conflicts. While the core principle of ensuring rest and providing nutrient-dense food for the mother is universally supported, many of the specific traditional restrictions are now understood to carry potential risks.
For example, the prohibition on bathing is contrary to modern hygiene standards, which emphasize cleanliness to prevent infection, particularly if the mother has had an episiotomy or a Caesarean section.25 Similarly, the traditional practice of discarding colostrum—the nutrient-rich first milk—because it is considered "stale" or "dirty" directly contradicts contemporary medical advice, which recognizes colostrum as a vital source of antibodies that provide the newborn with crucial passive immunity.20
Perhaps the most critical area of tension lies in the realm of mental health. The social isolation inherent in traditional confinement, while intended to be protective, is a known risk factor for postpartum depression and anxiety. A clinical study found a direct and statistically significant correlation between the duration of the confinement period and the incidence of mental distress in new mothers. The research revealed that extending confinement from under two weeks to over a month increased the odds of suffering mental distress by more than sevenfold, with 16 percent of participants reporting suicidal thoughts during the period.29 This suggests that a practice designed to be a period of intensive support can, in its strictest form, become a source of profound psychological strain.
This tension highlights that the enduring value of ge lai may not lie in its specific, centuries-old rules, but in its underlying philosophy of providing the new mother with a dedicated period of rest, nourishment, and social support, freeing her from all other obligations so she can focus on her recovery and bonding with her infant.30 The contemporary evolution of the practice reflects a cultural negotiation with these modern insights. The rise of specialized postpartum confinement centers and gourmet ge lai meal delivery services in many Hokkien communities represents an attempt to synthesize the best of both worlds.22 These modern adaptations aim to preserve the core benefit of the tradition—a structured, supportive recuperation period—while modifying or discarding the specific restrictions that conflict with current medical and psychological knowledge.
Table 1: An Analytical Overview of Hokkien Postpartum Confinement (Ge Lai) Practices
Practice / Belief | Traditional Rationale (TCM / Cultural) | Modern Scientific / Medical Perspective |
Dietary Focus on "Heating" Foods (e.g., ginger, pork, rice wine) | To restore yang (heat), replenish qi and blood lost during childbirth, and expel "cold" from the body.24 | Nutrient-dense foods are beneficial for recovery and lactation. Ginger has anti-inflammatory properties. However, excessive alcohol or unknown herbal substances can pass through breast milk and may harm the infant (e.g., worsen jaundice).25 |
Prohibition of Bathing / Hair Washing | To prevent "wind" (feng) and "cold" from entering the vulnerable postpartum body, which is believed to cause future ailments like rheumatism and headaches.22 | In an era without modern sanitation, this may have reduced infection risk. Today, it poses a hygiene risk. Regular bathing is medically recommended for cleanliness and comfort.25 |
Seclusion Indoors / Avoidance of Wind | To protect the weakened mother and infant from external pathogens and malevolent spiritual influences.20 | Reduces exposure to illness, which is beneficial for a newborn's underdeveloped immune system. However, complete lack of fresh air and sunlight can be detrimental. |
Strict Rest / Limited Physical Activity | To allow the body, particularly the uterus and pelvic floor, to heal from the trauma of childbirth.22 | Rest is crucial for recovery. However, complete bed rest can increase the risk of blood clots (deep vein thrombosis). Gentle, early ambulation is now encouraged.20 |
Social Isolation / Restriction of Visitors | To shield the mother and child from both germs and spiritual "pollution" during their vulnerable state.20 | Can be a protective measure against infection. However, prolonged social isolation is a significant risk factor for postpartum depression and anxiety. A strong support network is vital for mental health.29 |
Part III: Rites of Passage: Welcoming the Infant into the Community
Once the precarious initial month has passed, a series of formal rituals are enacted to mark the infant's successful transition from a vulnerable, liminal state to a fully recognized member of the family and the wider community. These rites of passage are not merely celebratory; they are powerful acts of social and spiritual integration that bestow an identity upon the child, announce their arrival to the ancestors, and reinforce the intricate web of kinship and social obligations that will define their life.
An Identity and a Destiny: Traditional Naming Practices
In Hokkien culture, as in broader Chinese tradition, a name is far more than a simple identifier. It is a vessel for the family's hopes, a reflection of their values, and a powerful element believed to influence the child's character and destiny.32 The naming process is therefore undertaken with great care and deliberation.
Traditionally, a child receives multiple names. Shortly after birth, parents often use a "milk name" (rǔmíng 乳名 or xiǎomíng 小名), an informal nickname used only by close family members.35 This name is often a term of endearment, but sometimes a deliberately unpleasant or humble name, such as "chicken droppings," is chosen based on the superstitious belief that it will make the child seem undesirable to malevolent spirits, thus protecting them from harm.33
The selection of the formal name, or mingzi (名字), is a much more serious affair. It is often done in consultation with respected elders, particularly the paternal grandfather, who traditionally holds the privilege of naming the child.36 Great importance is placed on choosing characters with auspicious meanings that reflect the virtues the parents hope their child will embody, such as wisdom (明), strength (强), or beauty (美).33 A crucial element in this process is consulting the child's "Eight Characters" (bāzì 八字), a form of astrological calculation based on the precise year, month, day, and hour of birth.23 A fortune teller or master of cosmology may be employed to analyze the bāzì to determine which of the five elements (wood, fire, earth, metal, water) is lacking in the child's constitution. A character containing the radical of the missing element is then incorporated into the name to create a more harmonious and auspicious balance, thereby ensuring a smoother path in life.32
The First Great Celebration: The Full Moon (Mǎnyuè 满月) Ceremony
The infant's first major rite of passage is the Full Moon, or Mǎnyuè (满月), celebration, held on the 30th day after birth.37 This event serves as the child's official introduction to the world and marks the formal end of the mother's confinement period.36 Historically, its significance was profound; in an era of high infant mortality, a baby surviving its first month was a momentous achievement worthy of a grand celebration.36 Today, it remains a joyous and pivotal occasion for the family, rich with symbolic rituals.
Key Rituals and Symbols:
Red Eggs and Ginger: The most iconic elements of the celebration are red-dyed eggs and pickled ginger, which are distributed to friends and relatives.37 The egg, with its round shape, symbolizes fertility, the cycle of life, and harmony, while the vibrant red color represents luck, happiness, and good fortune in Chinese culture.23 The sharing of ginger connects the celebration back to the mother's postpartum healing diet, signifying her successful recovery.36
Head Shaving: A central ritual of the day is the baby's first haircut. The fine hair the baby is born with, known as "blood hair" (xie fa), is traditionally shaved off.36 This act is believed to serve two purposes: spiritually, it cleanses the child of any impurities carried from the womb; practically, it is thought to stimulate the growth of a full, thick head of hair later in life.36 The shorn hair is sometimes preserved and made into a calligraphy brush as a keepsake for the child.36 Following the shaving, both mother and baby may take a ritual bath in water infused with pomelo leaves, which is believed to wash away bad luck and ward off evil spirits.36
Ancestral Announcement: The celebration includes a solemn moment where the infant is formally presented to the ancestors. The family will make offerings of food, such as ang ku kueh (red tortoise cakes), and incense at the ancestral altar, introducing the newest member of the lineage and asking for the ancestors' blessings and protection for the child's future.23
Gifts and Banquets: The Mǎnyuè is marked by a celebratory feast, which can range from an intimate family gathering to a large banquet at a restaurant, as depicted in videos of such events.42 Guests present gifts to the newborn, with the most traditional and valued gifts being hongbao (red envelopes containing money) and gold or silver jewelry, which symbolize wealth and good fortune.23 In turn, the new parents distribute gift boxes to their social circle, typically containing red eggs, cakes, and other treats, as a formal announcement of the birth and a gesture of gratitude.36
While the Mǎnyuè celebration is ostensibly a party to welcome a new baby, its intricate structure of gift-giving and ritual exchange reveals a deeper social function. The event is not merely a personal celebration but a powerful public ritual for the mobilization and reaffirmation of the family's social capital. The act of guests presenting hongbao and valuable gifts is more than simple generosity; it is a tangible investment in the social relationship with the new parents, creating a bond of reciprocity and mutual obligation that is central to the concept of guanxi (关系), or social networks. The family's distribution of elaborate gift boxes serves as a public proclamation of the birth that simultaneously reinforces these social ties.
Furthermore, specific rituals within the celebration, such as the "dressing up ceremony" (song tou wei), highlight the formal strengthening of kinship bonds. In this tradition, the maternal grandmother is obliged to provide a complete set of 12 gifts for the infant, including everything from clothing and blankets to gold jewelry.36 This is a highly symbolic act that publicly acknowledges and solidifies the crucial link between the father's and mother's lineages. For a culture like the Hokkien, with a long and successful history as merchants and traders where strong social and economic networks are paramount for success 9, the public performance and reinforcement of these bonds through such a pivotal life event is of the utmost importance. The Mǎnyuè is thus a sophisticated mechanism for weaving the new child, and by extension their nuclear family, securely into the broader social and economic fabric of the community.
Part IV: The Philosophy of Upbringing: Cultivating Character and Competence
Once the initial rites of passage are complete, the focus of Hokkien parenting shifts to the long-term project of jiaoyu (教育), or education and upbringing. This process is guided by core cultural principles that aim to cultivate a child who is not only academically successful but also morally upright, respectful, and deeply integrated into the family unit. Western observers have often interpreted these methods through the lens of "authoritarianism," a label that fails to capture the cultural nuances and motivations behind them. A deeper analysis reveals a complex philosophy of care that is now being re-examined and challenged by both internal cultural shifts and external empirical research.
Beyond Control: Deconstructing the Concept of Guan (管)
A foundational concept in Chinese parenting, and one that is frequently misunderstood, is guan (管). The term is often translated into English simply as "to control" or "to govern," which immediately conjures images of the "authoritarian" parenting style as defined in Western psychology—a style characterized by high demandingness and low responsiveness or warmth.27 This translation, however, strips the term of its rich cultural meaning.
As argued by scholar Ruth Chao, this interpretation is a significant cultural misreading.45 Within the Chinese cultural context, guan is a far more holistic concept. While it does include elements of governance, training, and discipline, it is inextricably fused with the meanings of "to care for" and "to love".45 From this perspective, parental control and strictness are not acts of domination but are understood as profound expressions of parental love, involvement, and investment. This form of "training" (chiaoshun) is seen as a parent's fundamental duty, an attempt to guide and protect the child, helping them to develop self-control and act in a socially acceptable manner to ensure their future success.27 This contrasts sharply with the Western conception of authoritarianism, which implies a coldness and emotional distance that is often absent in close-knit Chinese families. Chinese parents who employ strict discipline often do so with the assumption that the child will understand the underlying message of high expectations and trust, rather than perceiving it as ruthless punishment.27
A Critical Reassessment of the 'Tiger Parent': Evidence from Taiwan
The notion of a strict, demanding, and uniquely effective "Chinese" parenting style was globally popularized by the concept of the "Tiger Mother," a term coined by Amy Chua, who herself notes her family's Hokkien roots.46 The "Tiger Mom" philosophy posits that a highly demanding and monitoring approach is the key to producing academically and professionally successful children, and that this method is derived from a traditional Chinese cultural background.46 This stereotype has become a powerful, albeit controversial, shorthand for Chinese child-rearing.
However, empirical research conducted in Taiwan—a society where Hokkien culture is predominant—presents a far more nuanced and critical perspective that directly challenges this simplistic narrative.46 A comprehensive study on the relationship between parenting styles and children's achievement in Taiwan yielded several key findings that complicate the "Tiger Mom" myth:
First, the study found that while parents who held strong traditional Confucian values were indeed more likely to practice stricter parenting, they were simultaneously less likely to exhibit the cold and unresponsive behaviors associated with the clinical definition of "authoritarian" parenting. This suggests that traditional values in a Hokkien context promote discipline but not emotional distance.46
Second, and more strikingly, the research discovered a significant negative correlation between parenting strictness and children's academic performance and highest educational attainment. This finding directly contradicts the central premise of the "Tiger Parent" philosophy.46
The study's overall conclusion was a refutation of the idea that strict parenting within a Confucian cultural context is inherently beneficial for a child's achievement. It suggests that the perceived success of the "Tiger Mom" approach may be an artifact of specific socio-economic or immigrant contexts, where such methods are perceived differently, rather than a universal truth about Hokkien or Chinese child-rearing.46
The common assumption that a culture emphasizing filial piety and respect for authority would naturally produce a monolithic, authoritarian parenting style proves to be an oversimplification. The academic research from Taiwan effectively severs the presumed direct link between Confucian values and authoritarian methods.46 It reveals that while parents who embrace traditional values are indeed stricter, they tend to favor more benevolent and responsive approaches over cold, demanding control. This is further supported by broader longitudinal studies in mainland China, which document a clear and ongoing trend away from authoritarianism and towards authoritative (high warmth, high demandingness) and "autonomy-granting" parenting styles.47
This divergence reveals a crucial distinction between cultural goals and parenting methods. The core cultural values of the Hokkien—such as the importance of education, respect for elders, and family orientation—are not rigid blueprints for a specific parenting style. Instead, they represent a set of desired outcomes or virtues to be instilled in the next generation. What is changing is not necessarily the destination, but the path taken to get there. Modern Hokkien parents are increasingly demonstrating a sophisticated cultural adaptability, employing different, more psychologically-attuned methods to achieve the same culturally-valued ends. They are integrating modern understandings of child development to raise a child who is both successful and respectful, demonstrating that the "what" (the values) can remain constant even as the "how" (the parenting practice) evolves with the times.
Part V: Continuity and Change: Hokkien Parenting in the 21st Century
The landscape of Hokkien child-rearing today is a dynamic space where long-standing traditions coexist and interact with the powerful forces of modernization, globalization, and shifting state policies. While the foundational values of family and filial piety remain influential, the practical realities of raising a child in a 21st-century urban environment like Xiamen or Taipei have prompted significant adaptations in family structure, parenting beliefs, and the support systems available to new parents.
The Enduring Role of the Extended Family: Grandparents as Primary Caregivers
One of the most significant features of contemporary urban Hokkien family life is the central role played by grandparents in the raising of young children.15 In cities like Xiamen, it is common for grandparents to be deeply involved in daily childcare, a trend that was significantly amplified by the decades of China's one-child policy, which concentrated the hopes and resources of up to four grandparents and two parents onto a single child.49 Ethnographic research conducted in Xiamen reveals that nearly half of all households with primary school children involve grandparents in active childcare roles.49
This creates a complex, interdependent three-generation family system where child-rearing is a shared, and sometimes contested, responsibility.49 The traditional, unidirectional flow of authority from parent to child is complicated by this dynamic. The child is often an active agent who learns to navigate the different expectations and parenting philosophies of their parents and grandparents.49 This multi-generational caregiving structure, while providing invaluable support for working parents, also serves to transmit traditional values and practices directly from the older generation to the youngest, ensuring a degree of cultural continuity even amidst rapid social change.15
The Shift Towards Progressive Parenting
Concurrent with the enduring influence of grandparents is a clear and documented shift in the beliefs and practices of parents themselves. Across China, including in Hokkien communities, there is a discernible move away from traditional, obedience-focused parenting towards more progressive, child-centered approaches.48
Longitudinal studies have shown that Chinese parents today are more likely to endorse "progressive" child-rearing beliefs—which value attributes like creativity, independence, and self-direction—than "traditional" beliefs that prioritize conformity and adherence to authority.48 This shift in belief systems is mirrored in their actions. "Authoritative" parenting, which combines high levels of warmth and responsiveness with clear expectations and demands, has become more prevalent than the colder, more controlling "authoritarian" style.48 Furthermore, researchers have identified the emergence of a new "autonomy-granting" parenting style, reflecting a growing cultural valuation of children's self-directive behaviors in contemporary China.47 This evolution is not solely a product of Western influence; it is also driven by internal factors, including the widespread popularization of scientific knowledge about child development and the intense emotional and financial investment that parents in smaller families are able to make in each child.50
